Mantooth Insurance Agency has proudly served Hendricks County for the last 40 Years! Through these unprecedented times, we are committed to providing our local community with the peace-of-mind they deserve. Through our partnership with Erie Insurance, policyholders have received a 5% reduction in commercial and personal auto premiums for the last 2 months. We’re also offering a 5% rate reduction at the time of renewal to say “thank you” to our loyal customers for supporting us all these years! #ThankYou #LocalCommunity

Thank you for allowing Mantooth Insurance Agency to serve Hendricks County for the last 40 years! It has been our privilege to provide exceptional service and coverage to our community over the last four decades. To celebrate our anniversary and the class of 2020, we are awarding $500 scholarships to six exemplary students in the Hendricks County Public school system. The student chosen will have lived Erie Insurance's mantra: Above all in service.

Avon Indiana Independent Insurance Agencey

The Mantooth Insurance Agency meets your needs with our proven professional service, and the caring, conscientious attitude you expect.

Our company gives a new definition to fair and prompt settlement for your insurance claims. We go beyond the usual procedure of other Indianapolis insurance companies to meet all needs. Our agents are dedicated to offering the best plans from some of the country’s finest insurance companies to maximize our clients’ coverage.

Mantooth Insurance Agency puts our customers’ convenience and satisfaction above all else. We exert effort to reduce Indianapolis insurance costs through a comprehensive analysis of our clients’ needs. We’ll even provide a proposal for any type of coverage, be it personal, business, or financial.

We are an independent Indiana insurance company, but we also represent some of the state’s reputable firms. For more information about our services, call our toll free hotline at (317) 272-1010.


Request and Insurance Quote

Use our convenient 2-step quote form to request an insurance quote. It's quick and easy! Simply enter your personal information and answer a few questions and we will contact you with your quote.

Online Billing and Payments

Most of our insurance companies have the option for you to pay your premiums by EFT (Electronic Funds Transfer), e-check or by credit card. Fast online payments can prevent lapses in coverage and save you time.

File an Insurance Claim

If you have a claim to report, you can take advantage of the insurance carriers’ 24/7 Claim Support Service to report a claim directly to the insurance company claim department or you may contact Mantooth Insurance Agency.